Understanding Cartilage Injury

Articular cartilage is the smooth, glistening tissue that lines the ends of bones inside your knee joint. When this tissue is damaged — whether from a sports injury, a fall, or cumulative wear — the knee may lose its ability to absorb shock and glide freely. At Grossmont Orthopedic Medical Group, our fellowship-trained sports medicine surgeon Dr. Scott Hacker offers the full spectrum of cartilage restoration procedures to help appropriate candidates return to an active life.

Unlike muscle or bone, articular cartilage contains no blood vessels. Without a blood supply to deliver healing cells, cartilage cannot repair itself after injury. Even small chondral defects — localized areas of cartilage damage — may progressively enlarge over time and lead to significant pain, swelling, and functional limitation if left untreated. The good news is that surgical techniques have advanced considerably, and carefully selected patients may experience meaningful improvement with the right restoration procedure.

What Is Articular Cartilage?

  • ●
    Avascular tissue — articular cartilage has no blood supply, which is why it cannot self-repair the way a cut or fractured bone might heal on its own.
  • ●
    Focal defects vs. generalized arthritis — a chondral defect is a localized crater in an otherwise healthy joint surface, distinct from the widespread cartilage loss seen in osteoarthritis.
  • ●
    Common in active individuals — cartilage injuries are frequently found alongside ACL tears, patellar dislocations, and repetitive impact injuries in athletes and active adults.
  • ●
    Treatable with the right approach — multiple proven and emerging surgical techniques may restore a functional cartilage surface, reduce pain, and improve quality of life in appropriate candidates.

What Patients May Experience

Symptoms of Cartilage Damage

Chondral injuries may produce symptoms that overlap with other knee problems, which is why thorough evaluation — including MRI imaging — is important for accurate diagnosis. Signs may include:

  • Deep, aching pain localized to a specific area of the knee, often worsening with impact or prolonged activity
  • Swelling that develops during or after exercise and may persist for days following activity
  • A catching, locking, or clicking sensation when the knee passes through certain ranges of motion
  • Pain when kneeling, squatting, ascending or descending stairs, or pivoting
  • A feeling of the knee "not feeling right" even in the absence of overt pain, particularly during sport or exercise
  • Stiffness after periods of rest that eases with gentle movement

Ideal Surgical Candidates

Who May Benefit from Cartilage Restoration

Cartilage restoration procedures are not appropriate for every patient. The best outcomes tend to be seen in individuals who meet certain criteria:

  • Younger age — most restoration procedures are best suited for patients under 50, though age alone is not disqualifying
  • Focal, well-defined defects — a discrete area of cartilage damage on an otherwise healthy joint surface tends to respond better than widespread arthritis
  • Active lifestyle goals — patients motivated to complete a rigorous rehabilitation program and return to sport or high-level activity
  • Normal or correctable alignment — significant bowleg or knock-knee deformity may need to be addressed concurrently to protect the restored cartilage
  • Healthy surrounding tissue — the surrounding cartilage, meniscus, and ligaments should be relatively intact or simultaneously repaired
  • Appropriate body weight — excess mechanical load may compromise outcomes of cartilage repair procedures

Surgical Options

Cartilage Restoration Procedures

The appropriate procedure depends on the size and location of the defect, the patient's age and activity goals, and the condition of the surrounding joint. Dr. Hacker performs a thorough evaluation — including MRI review and often diagnostic arthroscopy — before recommending a specific approach.

Step 1 — Simplest

Chondroplasty (Cartilage Smoothing)

Performed arthroscopically, chondroplasty involves removing loose or frayed cartilage flaps that may catch within the joint and cause pain or swelling. While it does not regenerate lost cartilage, smoothing unstable tissue may reduce mechanical symptoms and improve comfort. This may be performed as a standalone procedure or in combination with other cartilage techniques.

Step 2 — Stimulation

Microfracture

Microfracture is one of the most commonly performed cartilage procedures. Using an arthroscope, the surgeon makes small perforations in the subchondral bone beneath the cartilage defect. These micro-holes allow blood and marrow stem cells to flow into the area, forming a clot that may gradually mature into fibrocartilage — a durable scar tissue that can cover the exposed bone surface and reduce pain. Microfracture may be most effective for defects smaller than approximately 2 to 3 cm² in younger patients. A strict weight-bearing restriction and continuous passive motion protocol during early recovery are often required to optimize outcomes.

Step 3 — Transplant

OATS / Mosaicplasty (Osteochondral Autograft Transfer)

OATS involves harvesting small cylindrical plugs of healthy cartilage and underlying bone from a lower-demand area of the patient's own knee and transferring them into the cartilage defect. When multiple plugs are used to fill a larger defect, the technique is called mosaicplasty. Because the transplanted tissue is the patient's own hyaline cartilage — the same type that originally lines the joint — the restored surface may more closely mimic normal cartilage than the fibrocartilage produced by microfracture. OATS tends to be best suited for defects in the range of 1 to 4 cm².

Step 4 — Cell-Based

ACI — Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation

ACI is a two-stage procedure designed for larger or more complex cartilage defects. In the first stage, a small sample of healthy cartilage cells (chondrocytes) is harvested arthroscopically from a low-impact area of the knee and sent to a laboratory, where the cells are cultured and multiplied over several weeks. In the second stage, the expanded cells are implanted into the defect beneath a patch of membrane. The new chondrocytes may mature into hyaline-like cartilage over six to eighteen months. ACI may be considered for defects larger than 3 to 4 cm² or when simpler procedures have failed.

Emerging

Biologic Approaches

Research into biologic adjuncts — including platelet-rich plasma (PRP), bone marrow aspirate concentrate (BMAC), and growth factor scaffolds — continues to evolve. These approaches may be used alongside established cartilage procedures to potentially enhance healing, reduce post-operative inflammation, and improve the quality of the regenerated tissue. Our physicians follow the evidence closely and may incorporate appropriate biologic adjuncts on a case-by-case basis.

Recovery: What to Expect

Recovery timelines vary significantly by procedure. Chondroplasty may allow relatively quick return to activity, while microfracture typically involves six to eight weeks of protected weight-bearing and six to twelve months before return to sport. OATS and ACI procedures often require nine to eighteen months of graduated rehabilitation before full athletic participation. In all cases, compliance with physical therapy is a critical determinant of outcome. Your GOMG surgeon and rehabilitation team will build an individualized recovery plan around your procedure, lifestyle, and goals.

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Is knee cartilage damage the same as arthritis? +

Not necessarily. Articular cartilage damage — also called a chondral defect — refers to a localized area of cartilage loss on the joint surface, often caused by an acute injury or repetitive stress in a younger, otherwise healthy knee. Osteoarthritis, by contrast, is a diffuse, generalized breakdown of cartilage throughout one or more compartments of the knee, typically developing over decades. Cartilage restoration procedures are best suited for focal defects in younger patients, while arthritis that has spread across the entire joint may require other interventions such as joint replacement.

Can damaged knee cartilage be repaired? +

Because articular cartilage has no blood supply, it cannot repair itself the way other tissues can. However, several surgical techniques may stimulate or replace cartilage tissue in the right candidates. Procedures such as microfracture, OATS (osteochondral autograft transfer), and ACI (autologous chondrocyte implantation) may help restore a functional cartilage surface, reduce pain, and improve joint function — particularly in younger patients with focal, well-defined defects.

What is microfracture surgery? +

Microfracture is an arthroscopic procedure in which a surgeon creates small perforations in the bone beneath a cartilage defect. These perforations allow blood and bone marrow cells to flow into the defect, forming a clot that may mature into fibrocartilage — a scar-like tissue that can cover the exposed bone and reduce pain. Microfracture may be most effective for smaller defects (typically under 2 to 3 cm²) in younger, active patients, and it is often combined with a structured rehabilitation program.

How long does cartilage restoration surgery recovery take? +

Recovery timelines vary considerably depending on the procedure, defect size, and location. Microfracture may require six to eight weeks of limited weight-bearing followed by months of progressive rehabilitation, with return to sport potentially taking six to twelve months. Larger procedures such as OATS or ACI generally involve longer recovery — often nine to eighteen months before full athletic activity. Your physician will develop a personalized rehabilitation protocol based on the specifics of your surgery and goals.

Our Specialists

Meet the Surgeons Who Perform Cartilage Restoration

Our cartilage restoration team includes a fellowship-trained sports medicine surgeon and a joint arthroplasty specialist who collaborate to offer the full continuum of knee care.

Dr. Scott A. Hacker, MD, MS

Sports Medicine & Arthroscopy

Dr. Scott A. Hacker, MD, MS

Fellowship-trained at the world-renowned Steadman-Hawkins Clinic in Vail, CO — one of the foremost centers for cartilage and ligament surgery. Team surgeon for the U.S. Olympic Team. Dr. Hacker specializes in the full spectrum of arthroscopic knee, shoulder, and hip procedures, with particular expertise in cartilage restoration, ACL reconstruction, and meniscus repair.

View Profile
Dr. Andrew E. Yoo, MD

Hip & Knee

Dr. Andrew E. Yoo, MD

Fellowship-trained in robotic-assisted total and revision hip and knee arthroplasty at UT Houston. Recipient of the Chief Resident Teaching Award at UC San Diego. Dr. Yoo provides a comprehensive approach to knee care, collaborating with Dr. Hacker to ensure patients whose cartilage damage may benefit from arthroplasty receive a smooth transition in their care.

View Profile

Think You May Have Cartilage Damage?

Contact Grossmont Orthopedic Medical Group in La Mesa, CA to schedule a consultation with our sports medicine and knee specialists. Early evaluation may expand your treatment options.

Book a Consultation 619.462.3131